Hamza Staff asked 3 years ago 
Will the Prophets Elijah and Esa, and Khidr ever appear again? And when?
1 Answers
Anis Staff answered 3 years ago The Syed (A.S) has reported that they will appear in the Minor Resurrection, as in [Al Jawab Al Munir, vol. 1. question 15](<a href=”https://ansars.at/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Al-Jawab-AlMonir-1.pdf” rel=”nofollow”>https://ansars.at/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Al-Jawab-AlMonir-1.pdf):
**”And Imam Mahdi (A.S), Isa (Jesus), Ilyas (Elijah), Khidr (PBUT) will come in the Minor Resurrection, which is a time for given account and for punishment and retribution against the transgressors, so is it correct to have the punishment and retribution without being warned? So, who is the warner? It is necessary for there to be a messenger from them (but) that gives glad tidings and warns mankind before them, i.e. before their appearance.”**
In other places, it is alluded to that by sending the Syed (A.S) on their behalf, they have also appeared, such as how Jesus (PBUH) would say ‘I say to you that Elijah has come, yet you did not recognise him’. Nevertheless, we do not doubt the veracity of the words of Syed Ahmed Al Hasan (PBUH) and will be expecting the appearance of these pious individuals in the coming period.
Original excerpt from Al Jawab Al Muneer vol 1:
والإمام المهدي (ع) وعيسى وإيليا والخضر (ع) يأتون في القيامة الصغرى وهي حساب وعذاب ونقمة على الظالمين، فهل يصح العذاب والنقمة قبل الإنذار ؟ فمن المنذر ؟
لابد أن يكون هناك رسول منهم (ع) يبشر وينذر الناس بين أيديهم، أي قبل ظهورهم،
**”And Imam Mahdi (A.S), Isa (Jesus), Ilyas (Elijah), Khidr (PBUT) will come in the Minor Resurrection, which is a time for given account and for punishment and retribution against the transgressors, so is it correct to have the punishment and retribution without being warned? So, who is the warner? It is necessary for there to be a messenger from them (but) that gives glad tidings and warns mankind before them, i.e. before their appearance.”**
In other places, it is alluded to that by sending the Syed (A.S) on their behalf, they have also appeared, such as how Jesus (PBUH) would say ‘I say to you that Elijah has come, yet you did not recognise him’. Nevertheless, we do not doubt the veracity of the words of Syed Ahmed Al Hasan (PBUH) and will be expecting the appearance of these pious individuals in the coming period.
Original excerpt from Al Jawab Al Muneer vol 1:
والإمام المهدي (ع) وعيسى وإيليا والخضر (ع) يأتون في القيامة الصغرى وهي حساب وعذاب ونقمة على الظالمين، فهل يصح العذاب والنقمة قبل الإنذار ؟ فمن المنذر ؟
لابد أن يكون هناك رسول منهم (ع) يبشر وينذر الناس بين أيديهم، أي قبل ظهورهم،
Please login or Register to submit your answer